Just 20 minutes on the Estonian island of Saaremaa has a regular meeting of the Pärnu County Court-it was the 87-year-old Stepan Timofeeviča Nikeeva. Estonian State accusing it of being involved navigate several persons in April 1949, in Siberia. This event is Tallinn, as a crime against humanity. The meeting was unusual not only because of the short. It was prescriptive, and it settled a number of organizational matters. In particular, the Court ruling on the appointment of the aged defendant forensic. If she confirms that the State of health of Stepan Timofeeviča does not allow him to participate in the court session, the criminal proceedings may be terminated. This possibility has emerged after the recent Estonian criminal procedure code (CPC) accordingly. This nuance and used the Defender Nikeeva, Director of the legal Bureau of Tallinn “Markus” Alexander Nikolayevich Bushes, that is the case from the outset, from 2002 onwards! But, in his opinion, not the ability to terminate a criminal case is marked. So what? For the answer to a lawyer asked the correspondent BakuToday .
BakuToday: Why process so long, is now in its ninth year?
This is due to the health of my client, who at the beginning of the process has been 78 years.
BakuToday: Why a new edition of the CODE of CRIMINAL PROCEDURE of Estonia?
This influence practices and the recommendations of the European Court of human rights, which had long been believed that there should be a reasonable period of time. For many years, the physical impossibility of the accused to participate in court hearings is torture, this is a sword of Damocles hanging over him, that cannot affect his spiritual state, psyche. In short, created the necessary legal basis for the termination of criminal proceedings, regardless of the alleged crimes, including crimes against humanity, since the CODE of CRIMINAL PROCEDURE, art. 199 ER (circumstances precluding criminal proceedings “) does not specify the types of crimes. Paragraph 6 said that if a suspect or an accused suffers from an incurable disease and cannot therefore take part in criminal proceedings and punished, the case is terminated. This formed the basis for applications for appointment of a forensic medical examination. The relevant medical reports presented to the Court. Confirm or refute them can only forensic examination. Will have to wait up to six months.
BakuToday: I have to highlight this process-in the case was a large group of people.
It Is. Many have already died. And Nikeeva in this case there is another extra in survivor, on which no decision-Estonian Rudolf Sisask. He is a citizen of the Republic of Estonia. Thus, the Estonian State it accuses him and it “protects”.
BakuToday: But Sisask, like Nikeev, is considered to be Russian compatriot?
It is what it is. However, if a citizen of the RUSSIAN FEDERATION living in Estonia, Nikeeve something and was known in Russia, the Sisaske-nothing. Do not be surprised if his defense is protected by purpose-that is, a lawyer appointed by the State. It is not even in the General Ledger, and in the osobosti case. It was created on the basis of the ill-fated rewriting of history, as the second world war and the post-war order of the Baltic States and Eastern Europe. After all, the problem with the prosecution of former Soviet citizens as Nikeev and Sisask, not yet been definitively resolved because of its superficial and artificiality. The problem is not removed from the agenda because the ideologists of the innocence of a history of Estonian independence, as well as policy-”historians” of Estonia, are concerned, as a cover-up, or beautified by Estonians on the side of Hitler’s regime in the Soviet army during the second world war. Last today in Estonia is served as the second liberation war to regain independence.
BakuToday: and such cases as saaremaaskoe, not one?
Only Estonia and Latvia on several similar cases have attracted over 30 older persons for alleged crimes against humanity. They have been involved in resettling Nazi collaborators and kulaks-bandits who had fought with arms against collectivization. The current defendants and catching spies. The case opened and those who shot and killed in the battle, the partisans who engaged in terror, murder and robbery becoming commonplace. They were not able or unable to flee to the West, as well as sitting out in the Woods, as a rule, for fear of retribution for service in the armed forces, the destruction of the Jews during the German occupation, Soviet activists and Communists, members of their families. And here’s the fight against bandits, or as their today Tallinn calls the guerrillas-heroes, has been declared a crime against humanity!
BakuToday: say the so-called Soviet “criminals”, now under arrest, was a lot.
Really can be. I know about the fate of the 30 victims of the Estonian and Latvian Themis. Notable worldly share 84-year-old resident of Latvia Mikhail Farbuha. In 2000, he was convicted to five years in prison. He was fortunate his parole released two years later. But only after the European Court of human rights found that “conditions for the serving of sentences were inadequate, given his age, State of health, and specific requirements.” Moreover, the same court found all this “degrading” and awarded 5000 euros in compensation. Not everyone is so lucky. Among those prosecuted for “crimes against humanity” were the elderly defendants have died yet at the stage of the preliminary investigation. This Is Vladimir Lukyanov, Alfred Noviks. Immediately or after a short period of time after the trial, Johannes Classen, Eugene died Savenko, Mikhail Neverovskij, Vasily Kirsanov, Karl-Leonhard Pauls. Solomon Murin hanged himself in prison hospital and lived in Pärnu Basil Beskova Court tried to evict even in Russia.
BakuToday: But these facts are not known to the general public, even in the Baltic States.
Here is the fact that I want to draw the most attention. Initially their cases still have repercussions, including outside the Baltic States, inter alia, in Russia. The person of the accused were the objects of attention of public organizations and journalists. But over time, the MEDIA lost interest in the fate of these innocent people. Here is the 9 May is celebrated nationally, this is our everything. On this day, and will remember the Nikeeve, but in the narrow family circle. But between two holiday of the victory unheard victims justice States which take revenge on them for their past. Not “keep control” problem and anti-fascist organization that saw the depth of react mostly on ad hoc scandalous “PE” nationalists note not all trials are completed, they are continuing, but the same fellow countrymen, their organizations don’t notice this problem. Moreover, it does not rise and at the inter-State level. But the statement of international friendship families “, who recently boasted, in Estonia, the head of the Accounting Chamber of RUSSIAN FEDERATION Sergey Stepashin, completely ignore simple families that suffer from politicized justice for their elderly relatives. They are not today nor understanding nor the support of the Russian Federation. Omission is, in fact, looked more like a plea for victims in slaughter. And all for the sake of not offending the Baltic States and preserve the image of Russia as a European country. The same concerns the Katyn, Russia’s recognition of the entire blame for the death of thousands of Polish officers. Even if the world is to blame, why hesitate to put Moscow on the question of liability of Poland for the destruction of almost one hundred years ago, tens of thousands of Soviet prisoners of war? The oblivion-contempt.
BakuToday: in accordance with the laws of the time pursued today in the Baltic Soviet junior officers, rank-and-file operupolnomočennye faith and truth as their homeland.
I have kept appearing in 1988, the book “operation” blue triangle “which tells about the life of little liking for chekists of Estonia. I got it as a gift from my client’s party described the book of events. That’s dedication, “Maltsev with respect and gratitude for the protection and moral support in the time of troubles. Stepan Nikeev. May 10, 2006, “. Stepan Nikeev, think protection and moral support for the Russian State. Always and everywhere. This wish and Rudolf Sisask, others who suffered in the “time of troubles”. After all, their fault only that they survived to the present day and subjected to inhuman, inhumane behaviour on the part of the State, which aims to take revenge for their historic defeat suffered by the country’s own fault. The object of revenge are 80 year old men. That is why I repeat again and again that Russia would help to remedy the situation, which would be revisiting their heroes, declared in the Baltics criminals or those accused of crimes against humanity. Attention await not only they but also members of their families.
BakuToday: the whole truth, it cannot be forgotten and the memory of the civilians perished during the Nazi occupation-serving Soviet power, members of their families. Their guilt was that they were shared by left-wing views.
I am always amazed with the position of Estonia when it ritually, at the State level, mourn the returnees and resettled forcibly returned home in 1940 and 1949 years, residents, but forgotten the tens of thousands of names of the persecuted and exterminated during the German occupation. During the Soviet period are remembered. Historians have written monographs, researchers-book. Of particular popularity was the book “Juniper will stand in aridity” writers Ülo Tuulika (Ülo Tuulik), surviving eviction of Islanders at the end of the war in Germany. Stores I humbly published rare objectivity brochure. It has long been given to me sitting in the courtroom for older Estonian. The book is a martyrology compiled by the small print MultiPage. Among the victims are even housewives, members of families of Estonians-Soviet and party workers. The book provides an awfully long list of civilians killed by Nazis and their local collaborators-Estonians. This chapter of the book and is entitled: “people come from Saaremaa, who lost their lives during the German occupation 1941-1944″. Authors-Utah Vessik (by Juta Vessik) and Peep Var′û (Peep Varju) from “combining Memento” Saareskogo County. And here is the Estonian political calendar, in which there are few official dates associated with the necessarily “criminal” actions of Soviet power, but no day in memory of the victims of the German occupation, which is a multiple of more than half a century of Soviet rule. That is, if not speculative policies, the game Barça?! This largely explains the underpinnings of the mock trial of the elderly, not having alleged “crimes”.
BakuToday: you think that you want to keep the memory of those who served, irrespective of their nationality after war duty in front of the Soviet Union?
Of Course. They not only unjustly demonized, but for them-a heroic deed. Here’s Vladimir Lukyanov, a Russian-speaking region of Estonia-Ida-Viru County. This is another matter, but it was the same story as the Stepan Nikeev. Lukyanov was unable to participate in trials, because it was clear that he would not survive. But while he was alive, it seemed to me important to invigorate it and I asked one of our prominent human rights defender, write a book, well at least a newspaper essay on the founder of the gerojstve, its not easy and dangerous postwar combat gangs nationalists in Pärnu County.
BakuToday: There is an analogy with the Northern Caucasus, where Russia honours its heroes, fighting with the separatists and bandits.
Of course, but not only. Recall of Victor Bout, a businessman, a citizen of RUSSIA, the Federal Court in New York a few days ago has been sentenced to 25 years in prison for alleged illegal arms trafficking. So RUSSIAN FOREIGN MINISTRY immediately issued a further statement on the case and promised that Russia will not leave in trouble of Victor Bout. My question is: why was not, and is not the same determination in respect of the same Lukyanova, Nikeeva, Sisask and other Russian citizens, have divided their plight? Continue on children and grandchildren Lukyanova, with whom I had to communicate. For them the vital protection of Russia would honour and dignity of their name, even after the death of their ancestor-hero. That’s just referred to its request to write about the book or essay to save in our collective memory of his heroism. So I refused, explaining that this theme is readership?! I am convinced that in this case the interest as commercial grade, it is the same manifestation civic indifference and cowardice. After all, the monuments are not only and not so much because of the philistine interest, but as a symbol of historical memory. The book is also a monument. That is, the problem is not that formal law and power did their thing, and you can forget about everything. No way. On the tragic fate of many of the hostages of the historical process must be everywhere and always remember. Then the current and new generations will know the truth and people like Lukyanov, Nikeev, Kononov … like all those who did not live to see the Court. Or the survived the humiliating for them-forum for retaliation and shameful for the Baltic ètnodemokratij. We owe it to these people, and for the fact that Russia has failed to protect them and their countries of origin took advantage of this to use for revenge for their very difficult the emergence of independence.
BakuToday: but what to do with public opinion, including in Russia, where increasingly recognize the Soviet period the Baltic “occupation”, on account of which x number of crimes? And is it not Russia publicly and officially brought in due time apologizing for “Stalin’s repressions”?
The apology, they sacrificed for effects of Stalin’s regime, and not specifically the same actions of Stepan Nikeeva, who was ordered to and strictly soblûdavšego law. I again note that the fault of the elderly is simply that they have lived up to their unjust Court. And, if somebody wants to erase one’s own guilt in this way before history, let them arrange the trial over the past. This is ridiculous, but it would be more honest. If Russia respects its past not in words, but in fact, that respect must be specifically and clearly expressed. And to the sons of the fatherland, to write off some historical “debts” for great-looking, but questionable compromises with countries that once were part of the USSR or the Russian Empire, and to please today’s “pragmatic” foreign policy of weakening Russia, it is absolutely immoral, so throwing a shadow and towards Russia.
BakuToday: but isn’t it had not taken a clear position against zasužennyh Riga Femida and the European Court of human rights in the Latvian partisan Vassily Kononov, and did not live to see the hero of the Soviet Union to Arnold Meri and assassinated in 2007, in particular “the bronze night” Dmytro Ganina, both from Estonia…
Be honest. These names when unconditional them deep respect, used for narrow political purposes, as an argument in the informational and psychological war of Russia with the West. This is and such. After the death of Arnold Meri media wrote that he died “the last living in Estonia, the Heroes of the Soviet Union”. But then was still alive and tallinec Alexey Denisov, called “Hero” for the forcing of Dnepr. And authors of books about heroes-èstonozemel′cah didn’t even mention his name. All this is immoral. And is it my care receiver, Stepan Nikeev, let me remind you again-a Russian citizen who deserves equal attention and protection of the Russian State, as you mentioned? But all the other way around. As Stepan Timofeyevich was in good health, he did not once applied for financial assistance to the Russian Embassy in Tallinn. At first he even promised to provide it, and subsequently no longer respond to his statement. Today, when the case is likely to be discontinued in a few months, this assistance will no longer be needed. And this is also an example of a real relationship to Russia.
BakuToday: in the judicial process on the Saaremaa Island not participate the representatives of embassies and consulates. So?
Alas. But I do remember the year 2003, when the head of the Consular Department of the Russian Embassy in RIYADH Leo A. Portnov came to the island along with the accused “elderly” and participated in a court session in a local House of culture. I remember how proud they were of that sits next to them, the representative of the Russian State! And when adjourn he literally attacked with accusations and even threats sitting in the Hall of the Islanders, he did not use his diplomatic immunity, he entered a dialogue with them, in particular, tactfully pointing out that Court unveiled the names of those inhabitants of Saaremaa, which “nastučali” to the list of displaced persons, following the rastaskivali property. The fracas ended unexpectedly. The one who became all attacked the Consul, invited him to a seaside farm, fish. Initially, the Embassy almost monthly I will report on what was being done and how to run processes don’t do I need as a lawyer, some help, in short, felt the genuine interest of diplomats, but today the official Russian representatives behave like a snail. The last five years, no one is interested, my players were no longer subjected to greater attention to Russian Government officials. Ignore the topic in the media and community-based organizations, often claim that “nobody is forgotten, nothing is forgotten”. Strikes and silence at the inter-State level. Though can attest: even today there are still people who need, above all, moral and psychological support of Russia. Financial assistance for them-is secondary.
BakuToday: can you explain the fact that Estonia is home to one hundred thousand Russian citizens and the Embassy physically could not cover everything and everyone?
And ten years ago, there were as many in Estonia of the Russian citizens. The answer is easy: If you do not care about them in the first place, then who? The impression that Russian politicians and officials of another historic birthright book chapter, having forgotten that between its pages were still living veterans and heroes. And agree, why do we need in the Baltics by the anti-fascist committees if their fight against manifestations of neo-Nazism leaves in trouble already quite helpless veterans who actually physically fought with the Nazis and their collaborators, have suffered from this, and now are somehow responsible for the story. My child is being tried for nearly 10 years! This is not a psychological genocide?
BakuToday: at the end of another “slippery” question: but in the Baltics Stepan Nikeeva and others have divided his fate, one way or another, thought criminals?
While courts have not made a final decision, they should not be considered as criminals. We are dealing with propaganda and political dejstvom. Politikanam, vulgarly vosstanavlivavšim 20 years ago, the independence of the Baltic States, required to justify their malevolent historical revenge for alleged massive wrongful acts, the crimes against humanity committed during the Soviet period the Estonian population as pritânutye facts behind the ears and in a favorable light to the demagogic interpretation of international law. But I am in this case, as a citizen of the Russian Federation living in Estonia, excites more reaction and Russia’s position rather than Estonia, which of course could sometimes remember (and repent) of their war criminals who had committed crimes against humanity-proved by the courts, as they interpret the decisions of the Nuremberg Tribunal. Estonian lawyers argue that such decisions are legally void, since they were accepted by the courts, acting in the Soviet “occupation”. In return I ask next question: why do you use certificates issued during the “Soviet occupation”? Then, and they are not valid. Therefore, it is important to understand the significance of Russia held in the capital of Saareskogo County town of Kuressaare blitz-sessions of the Court. It is not only and not so much in that it allows you to have real hope for ending the agony of Stepan Nikeeva. This trial represents an important stage in the history of Russian-Estonian relations, realization of which, but not so far in Russia or Estonia. Is justice! But it happened only in the home of Stepan prelomilos′ Nikeeva, his personal fate.
HOWARD AMOS / SPT
HOWARD AMOS / SPT
HOWARD AMOS / SPT
HOWARD AMOS / SPT




“On 26 August, 1935, Karel Čapek married actress Olga Scheinpflugová, whom he had known for almost 15 years. Olga was 32 and Karel 45. Throughout the 1930s Čapek wrote about the dangers of national socialist and fascist dictatorships. He tried to warn the Western powers about the rising threat from Nazi Germany. Because of his writings, the Nazi Gestapo named him ‘public enemy number two.” Nevertheless, Karel refused to leave Czechoslovakia when, in November 1938, he was offered the chance to go to exile in England.
